My Old Ass
Directed by Megan Park
★★★★½
Maisy Stella and Aubrey Plaza in My Old Ass
Credit: MARNI GROSSMAN © AMAZON CONTENT SERVICES LLC
Description: Maisy Stella and Aubrey Plaza in My Old Ass Photo MARNI GROSSMAN © AMAZON CONTENT SERVICES LLC
Megan Park’s My Old Ass is a fresh, high-concept coming-of-age story that effortlessly balances whimsy, heart, and introspection. The premise alone—a free-spirited 18-year-old Elliott (Maisy Stella) encountering her wisecracking 39-year-old self (Aubrey Plaza) during a mushroom trip—suggests a raucous comedic ride. However, what truly makes this film shine is its surprising restraint, focusing on the everyday challenges and triumphs of Elliott’s life rather than veering too far into the outrageousness the concept might imply. This tonal choice elevates My Old Ass into a deeply human and resonant story, making it one of the year’s standout films.
At its core, the film is about self-reflection and growth. Elliott’s life is in flux: navigating family dynamics, budding romances, and the daunting prospect of adulthood. Her 39-year-old self, affectionately referred to as her “old ass,” serves as both a comedic foil and a poignant reminder of the complexities that lie ahead. Aubrey Plaza is a revelation in the role, bringing her signature wit and biting humor to the character while injecting it with a surprising depth. Her scenes are some of the film's highlights, and even when Plaza’s presence is felt rather than seen, her performance resonates.
Yet, it’s Maisy Stella who truly anchors the film. As Elliott, Stella delivers a performance that is both raw and endearing, capturing the restless energy and vulnerability of adolescence with remarkable authenticity. Her portrayal makes Elliott’s journey feel deeply personal, and it’s no exaggeration to predict that Stella’s name will soon be on everyone’s radar. She handles the emotional beats of the story with such precision and heart that it’s impossible not to root for her.
The supporting ensemble is equally strong, each character bringing their own unique flavor to Elliott’s world. Whether it’s her loving parents, quirky best friends, or unexpected romantic interests, every performance feels lived-in and sincere. This collective effort elevates the film, adding layers of warmth and humor that make Elliott’s world feel real and relatable.
Megan Park, who already impressed with her debut feature The Fallout, cements herself as a filmmaker to watch with My Old Ass. Her script is sharp, balancing laugh-out-loud moments with poignant reflections on the choices that shape our lives. Park’s direction is equally assured, leaning into the intimacy of Elliott’s journey while still delivering on the concept’s inherent comedy. Her ability to craft authentic relationships and meaningful character arcs shines through, making the film a deeply affecting experience.
Despite its fantastical premise, My Old Ass is grounded in universal truths about growing up and confronting the person you might become. It’s heartwarming, validating, and, at times, gut-wrenchingly funny. The film doesn’t rely on its concept as a crutch but instead uses it as a lens to explore Elliott’s transformative summer in a way that feels fresh and unique.
My Old Ass is a testament to the power of smart storytelling and exceptional performances. It’s a must-see for anyone who’s ever wondered what advice their future self might give—or, perhaps, ignored it altogether. Megan Park, Maisy Stella, and Aubrey Plaza have crafted something truly special, and it’s a film that will linger with audiences long after the credits roll.
